Madden 10 vs NFL 2k5 (ps2)?

I'm going to try to get one of these games tomorrow for my playstation. I would like to know in your opinions which one is better graphics, easier to update rosters, game play (glitches, A.I, etc.), and franchise. And please don't say why don't you get madden 11 and why do you want 2k5 it's 5 years old unless your saying that cause it'll be harder to update rosters or something. Thanks, best answers gets 10 points.